Fire Island Vacation Rentals | Book Now, Save Up to 30%

All in pricing: Taxes and fees included

Save $552

Entire home in Bay Shore, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$1,881/night

New

7 bedrooms

16 guests

$6,896$6,345total

Save $103

Guests rave

Vacation Rental in Bay Shore, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$130/night

4.9

100

1 bedroom

2 guests

$504$401total

Save $231

Vacation Rental in Bay Shore, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$189/night

4.7

42

2 bedrooms

8 guests

$817$586total

Save $332

Vacation Rental in Bay Shore, NY

Dec 6 - 9

$245/night

4.9

15

3 bedrooms

8 guests

$1,092$760total

Save $86

Guests rave

Vacation Rental in Bay Shore, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$134/night

4.9

25

1 bedroom

2 guests

$499$414total

Save $160

Guests rave

Vacation Rental in Bay Shore, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$130/night

4.9

78

1 bedroom

2 guests

$562$401total

Save $151

Guests rave

Vacation Rental in Bay Shore, NY

Dec 6 - 9

$147/night

4.9

88

1 bedroom

2 guests

$605$455total

Save $210

Preferred host

Entire home in Patchogue, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$531/night

4.8

18

3 bedrooms

6 guests

$2,003$1,793total

Save $120

Unit 1 of 2

Preferred host

Entire rental unit in Bay Shore, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$409/night

5.0

5

3 bedrooms

6 guests

$1,500$1,380total

Save $75

Unit 2 of 2

Preferred host

Entire home in Bay Shore, NY

Nov 23 - 26

$254/night

5.0

2

1 bedroom

4 guests

$931$857total

Save $153

Preferred host

Entire home in Hauppauge, NY

Nov 17 - 20

$522/night

5.0

1

4 bedrooms

8 guests

$1,914$1,761total

Save $73

Preferred host

Entire rental unit in Deer Park, NY

Nov 22 - 25

$204/night

4.3

14

4 bedrooms

8 guests

$760$687total

Save $689

Guests rave

Entire home in Commack, NY

Nov 17 - 20

$748/night

5.0

191

3 bedrooms

7 guests

$3,224$2,535total

Save $144

Preferred host

Entire rental unit in Shirley, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$491/night

5.0

2

3 bedrooms

6 guests

$1,802$1,658total

Save $85

Preferred host

Entire rental unit in Dix Hills, NY

Nov 29 - Dec 2

$289/night

5.0

4

2 bedrooms

4 guests

$1,060$975total

Save $122

Whimstay gem

Entire home in Mastic Beach, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$417/night

4.9

52

3 bedrooms

6 guests

$1,529$1,407total

Save $69

Apartment in Mastic Beach, NY

Dec 26 - 29

$236/night

New

3 bedrooms

6 guests

$864$795total

Save $202

Preferred host

Entire home in Huntington Station, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$394/night

4.9

13

3 bedrooms

8 guests

$1,533$1,331total

Save $143

Preferred host

Entire rental unit in Huntington Station, NY

Nov 30 - Dec 3

$220/night

5.0

3

1 bedroom

4 guests

$886$744total

Save $515

Preferred host

Entire home in Westhampton Beach, NY

Apr 15 - 22

$752/night

4.8

12

5 bedrooms

10 guests

Pay only $666 today

$6,432$5,917total

Save $221

Guests rave

House in Wading River, NY

Nov 16 - 19

$593/night

4.9

35

3 bedrooms

6 guests

$2,228$2,008total

View all properties in Bay Shore

Map shows last minute vacation rentals in Fire Island