1 / 15

Walking distance to everything- Newly renovated!

Apartment in Algoma, WI

5 guests·2 bedrooms·1 bathroom
4.9 · 14 reviews

Why you'll love this stay

Location & Accessibility

Location & Accessibility

Walk to winery, beach, and downtown attractions from a stylish base.

Entertainment & Amenities

Entertainment & Amenities

Renovated interiors with cozy seating, smart TV, and guest-friendly futon.

Group & Family Friendly

Group & Family Friendly

Comfortable space ideal for group getaways with games and seating.

What guests are saying

Summarized with AI
Star icon

4.9

Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 14 reviews

Guests consistently highlight the charm and comfort of this property, often describing it as a great choice for stays in Door County. Many appreciate the convenient location, which offers easy access to local shops and the beach. The property is noted for its cozy atmosphere, with thoughtful amenities that enhance the experience. Although some guests mentioned minor issues with specific furnishings, the overall sentiment remains positive, making it a recommended option for travelers.

See all 14 reviews.

Property details

Welcome to the property manager!! Completely renovated 2 bed/1ba plus bonus futon couch. We are located directly across the street from Von Stiehl Winery and are just a few minutes walk to Crescent Beach! Welcome to the property manager!! Completely renovated 2 bed/1ba plus bonus futon couch. We are located directly across the street from Von Stiehl Winery and are just a few minutes walk to Crescent Beach! Please note that we are on the second story of the apartment building, and it is not handicap accessible. If you are unable to take the stairs, you may want to consider booking on the first floor. :) This property is a 9-unit apartment building. We do have other long-term renters in the building in units 6-9. Laundry: We do not have any washer and dryer hookups however we are lucky enough to have a laundry mat right next door! Bugs: Even though we have sprayed inside and outside twice a year, we are by the water! You can expect to see a few insects here and there. Door lock: Just a hint on the door code, if you touch it to light it up that will count as the first number. Try to touch the first number of the code you were given followed by the remaining 3 numbers. The numbers are in the same location as a phone key pad. The property does have parking lot with one designated parking space per unit. For example if you are staying in unit 5, you will be designated parking spot number 5. If you have more than one of car, there is additional parking on the road or at the park down the street. Each unit has 1 parking spot in the parking lot. The parking spot has each unit number listed on the pavement. There is free parking anywhere on the side of streets. the property manager is directly walking/biking distance to everything in Algoma, from being across the street from Von Stiehl Winery, Von Stiehl Cider Bar, Anaphee Brewery, Smashed on the Rocks, charter fishing, downtown shopping and food, and the beautiful sand beach and boardwalk. My husband and I also frequently stay here, I’m letting you know as we may see each other in passing! Algoma, Wisconsin is a quaint community nestled on the western shore of Lake Michigan at the southern end of the Door Peninsula. Come and take the Charter fishing trip of a lifetime on Lake Michigan, stroll the beautiful sand beach and boardwalk, relax with a glass of wine from a historic winery or spend the day shopping and sightseeing. There is something for everyone! No matter what you plan to enjoy in Northeast Wisconsin, Algoma is the ideal place to call home base. You can enjoy the peace and quiet and all that Algoma offers while being just a short drive away from Door County to the north, Scenic HWY 42 to the south, and Green Bay to the west. Note: This unit has completed its renovations however we are waiting on our professional photos. The decor is similar but not the exact layout. This unit will include a green velvet couch and gold hardware. To access Unit 5 you will want to enter through the door with the side lights, which is accessed and visible from the parking lot. You will go up the stairs on your right and Unit 5 will be the first door to your left on the second story. Opening the front door you will find the floors to have all new luxury vinyl flooring and tastefully decorated. In the living room I have chosen the seating arrangement to be conversational and inviting. This includes an 84” sleeper futon couch, relaxing furniture, board games, variety of books and a large smart TV. Note: There is also an AC window unit located in the living room. If the temperature is hot outside, I recommend to turn the AC unit on when you check in so you can cool the suite off while your outside enjoying the town! Through the living room opens to the hallway with the bathroom and bedrooms. The bathroom is fully renovated which includes a tub/tiled shower and beautifully designed tile floor. Each bedroom is furnished with a queen bed and one of them is set up with a desk and chair for those who still need to do some work on vacation. Note: The bedroom to the right has a locked door. Inside the locked door are extra supplies for our cleaners. The bedroom to the left has plenty of hangers for everyone to utilize. Entering into the kitchen which has all new cabinetry and full tile wall backsplash. I have added a counter height dining room table which includes 4 chairs. The kitchen also has an exit door that leads out to the other staircase. You can use the same code for either door to exit/enter the building. We are beginning renovations on this property in May 2022. I take great care in designing properties specifically with relaxation in mind and can't wait for you to relax and enjoy this property that is within walking distance to everything in Algoma! Check Out Instructions: Check out time is BY 11:00 AM- Our cleaner will be there at 11:00 AM sharp to ensure she has enough time to clean the property to professional standards before the next check in. Please note: You will be charged a $60.00 LATE CHECKOUT FEE for ALL unapproved late checkouts. Food- Please remove ALL food from the fridge, freezer and pantry and dispose of. Garbage/Recycling- Please remove all garbage and recycling from bathroom, bedrooms, living room and kitchen and place into the large dumpster outside of the building. Dishes- Please wash all dishes before you leave, dish soap and drying rack is located under the sink. Linens- Please leave all used beds unmade so the cleaning company knows they were used. Windows/Doors- Please walk around the apartment and ensure all windows are closed/locked. AC Unit- During the warm months, please turn off the air conditioner. Heat- During the cold months, please turn heat down to 60 degrees. TV- Sign out of any streaming accounts. Loose Items- Please double check for anything you may have forgotten. We are not responsible for any items left behind. Furniture- Move all furniture back to its original position if you have moved it!

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1

1 Queen Bed

Bedroom 2

1 Queen Bed

LIVING ROOM

1 Futon Bed

What’s included

  • Self check-in

    Self check-in

  • Parking

    Parking

  • Air conditioning

    Air conditioning

  • Heating

    Heating

  • Kitchen

    Kitchen

  • Wi-Fi

    Wi-Fi

  • Dedicated workspace

    Dedicated workspace

  • Waterfront

    Waterfront

Guest reviews

Star icon 4.9 | 14 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
O

Oleksandr

Star Icon 0 0Star Icon 0 1Star Icon 0 2Star Icon 0 3Star Icon 0 4

April 2026

A wonderful apartment—definitely 5 stars! A huge thank you to Chris and Joel for a magnificent job—everything has been thought out down to the smallest detail; it is cozy, beautiful, and extremely comfortable. We absolutely loved everything about it! We would happily return again and definitely recommend this place to everyone—it truly lives up to a five-star standard.

L

Lynn Kennedy

Love the Steele Magnolia!!

Star Icon 1 0Star Icon 1 1Star Icon 1 2Star Icon 1 3Star Icon 1 4

January 2026

We visit Algoma a couple of times a year and we love staying here. The units are always clean and the customer service is fabulous! We also love the location. 5 stars!!

M

Marianne

Star Icon 2 0Star Icon 2 1Star Icon 2 2Star Icon 2 3Star Icon 2 4

August 2025

The space we stayed in at the Steele Magnolia is beautiful! Krissi has done a wonderful job creating a space where we felt comfortable, and also pampered. The building is within walking distance of lake Michigan, we could actually see it from the windows! The town caters to those who want to fish, but it's a great starting point for exploring the rest of Door County. We enjoyed going to the local coffee shop, exploring the town and walking along lake Michigan while in Algoma. We also drove up through Door County and visited many of the towns along the way while making our way up to Washington Island which we'd also highly recommend. All in all a great getaway and we enjoyed our stay at The Steele Magnolia!

R

Rodrigo

Star Icon 3 0Star Icon 3 1Star Icon 3 2Star Icon 3 3Star Icon 3 4

February 2025

Greatest experience...!!! thank you Krissi...!!! 👍🙏👍

Know before you go

Self check-in

House rules

Check-in: 3:00pm

Checkout: 11:00am

Pets allowed

No smoking

No parties

Have a question about this property?

Site Footer

Get deals directly in your inbox:

© 2026 Whimstay, Inc. All Rights Reserved. “SEIZE THE STAY” and “WHIMSTAY” are registered trademarks of Whimstay, Inc. and the W Logo is a trademark of Whimstay, Inc.