1 / 34

Nellie May Cabin on Vallecito Lake in Bayfield CO

Cabin in Bayfield, CO

4 guests·2 bedrooms·1 bathroom
4.8 · 22 reviews

Why you'll love this stay

Outdoor Living

Outdoor Living

Relax on a large private deck with firepit and grill.

Location & Accessibility

Location & Accessibility

Short 5-minute walk to Lake Vallecito and marina access.

Style & Comfort

Style & Comfort

Cozy mountain cabin with wood stove and peaceful forest views.

What guests are saying

Summarized with AI
Star icon

4.8

Rated 4.8 out of 5 from 22 reviews

Guests consistently praise this property for its cleanliness, comfort, and thoughtful arrangements. Many highlight the peaceful atmosphere and beautiful views of the lake and surrounding nature. Reviewers appreciate the well-equipped kitchen and the easy communication with management. The cabin's charm and tranquility make it a favorite among visitors, who express a strong desire to return for future stays.

See all 22 reviews.

Property details

Come relax at Nellie May Cabin featuring a large, private deck with a propane grill and firepit. It is a quick 5-minute walk down to Lake Vallecito and is close to the marina, restaurants and grocery store. Enjoy cool afternoon breezes overlooking Lake Vallecito from the large deck at the Nellie May Cabin. Just a few minutes' walk through the trees and you arrive at the lake side. Nellie May is close to the marina, restaurants, liquor stores, and grocery stores. This charming cottage-style cabin is the perfect spot for your next getaway. The cabin boasts a spacious full kitchen, two bedrooms, a full bath, a cozy living room with a large picture window, propane grill and firepit on the deck, a wood-burning stove, and a loft with a hammock for afternoon naps. Play all day at the lake or on the trails and then relax in a quiet evening on the deck with its gas firepit or in front of the wood-burning stove. Enjoy a night out at the Weminuche Woodfire Grill, which generally has music on the weekends. Lounge in the morning sun as you dig into your freshly made burrito at the La Comida Ranchera Mexican Restaurant. Nellie May offers a memorable Colorado mountain cabin experience. We provide an outdoor dog pen for your furry friend when you're at the cabin. WHERE YOU'LL SLEEP: * Bedroom #1 - Queen bed * Bedroom #2 - Queen bed LOCATION: In the heart of the Lake Vallecito recreation area, you are near the marina, hiking, biking and ATV trails, fishing, hunting, ice fishing, snowshoeing and snowmobiling - the San Juan wilderness area is at your doorstep! Vallecito also has a few restaurants and general stores. Appx 25 miles to downtown Durango and 50 miles to Purgatory Ski Resort. The dirt road down to the cabin can be bumpy. PETS: This home is pet friendly! We allow a maximum of 2 dogs max and the pet fee is $40/day (for a max $250 per stay). Pets must be crated if they are left home alone. We do have a fenced outdoor pen area for your dog to play while you are outside with them. COOLING: Please note that, like most properties in the area, this home does not have AC, as it is uncommon for homes at this elevation. Temperatures inside the property are easily managed by using fans and opening the windows at night when temperatures drop into the 40s. GOOD TO KNOW: This cabin does not have a washer/dryer or a dishwasher. Stay with us and we offer DISCOUNTS on both summer (white water rafting, horseback riding etc.) and winter (ski/snowboard rentals, sleigh rides, snowmobile tours etc.) activities. ABOUT YOUR HOST: At (VRC), we’re a professional management company that takes pride in delivering a consistent, high-quality experience across all of our homes. The difference means you can always expect locally owned and operated service with a personal touch and insider knowledge of the area. We offer 24/7 guest communication and lightning-fast response times whenever you need assistance. Each property is professionally cleaned and meticulously maintained to ensure comfort and peace of mind, and every home is inspected before arrival to make sure every detail is guest-ready. POLICY: At we understand the importance of flexibility for travelers when it comes to cancellations. When booking directly with we offer a Policy for this Property: A guest will receive a 100% refund if canceled/changed at least 30 days before check-in; a 50% refund if canceled/changed 14-30 days before check-in; and no refund if canceled/changed 13 days or less before check-in. We do offer travel insurance. Minimum age to book this property is : 25

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1

2 Queen Beds

What’s included

  • Self check-in

    Self check-in

  • Parking

    Parking

  • Heating

    Heating

  • Pets allowed

    Pets allowed

  • Kitchen

    Kitchen

  • Wi-Fi

    Wi-Fi

  • Deck

    Deck

  • Waterfront

    Waterfront

Guest reviews

Star icon 4.8 | 22 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
J

Jack B.

Lake fishing

Star Icon 0 0Star Icon 0 1Star Icon 0 2Star Icon 0 3Star Icon 0 4

July 2026

Old and quaint, just like us!

K

Kate

Star Icon 1 0Star Icon 1 1Star Icon 1 2Star Icon 1 3Star Icon 1 4

July 2026

Location had everything we needed for a great stay. Well equipped. Close to the lake. Great communication. Would be happy to stay there again!

R

Rachelle

Star Icon 2 0Star Icon 2 1Star Icon 2 2Star Icon 2 3Star Icon 2 4

July 2025

our first time at Vallecito Lake. this place was just right! there was a path to the lake right from the cabin! we also ate most all of our meals on deck outdoors with pines all around. other cabins are close by but we didn't hear or see people because of the trees!

H

Hannah & Adam

Star Icon 3 0Star Icon 3 1Star Icon 3 2Star Icon 3 3Star Icon 3 4

July 2025

Cute and cosy cabin a few minutes walk from the lake.

Know before you go

Self check-in

House rules

Check-in: 4:00pm

Checkout: 10:00am

Pets allowed

Min. age to rent: 25

No smoking

No parties

Have a question about this property?

Site Footer

Get deals directly in your inbox:

© 2026 Whimstay, Inc. All Rights Reserved. “SEIZE THE STAY” and “WHIMSTAY” are registered trademarks of Whimstay, Inc. and the W Logo is a trademark of Whimstay, Inc.