1 / 36

Key Lime Cottage in Islamorada

Vacation Rental in Islamorada, FL

5 guests·2 bedrooms·1 bathroom

Why you'll love this stay

Outdoor Living

Outdoor Living

Private pool area with fire pit and tropical outdoor lounge.

Location & Accessibility

Location & Accessibility

One mile from Robbie's Marina; endless snorkeling and dining nearby.

Entertainment & Amenities

Entertainment & Amenities

Includes free paddleboards for effortless island exploration.

Property details

Relax, Recharge & Explore – Detached Islamorada Cottage w/ Pool, Paddleboards & Fire Pit ☀️

Welcome to your own private cottage in paradise — perfectly located in Islamorada, just a mile from the legendary Robbie’s Marina, where feeding massive tarpon, grabbing a drink at the Hungry Tarpon, or hopping on a snorkeling charter is all part of a normal day.

This detached 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom cottage is ideal for couples, friends, solo adventurers, or small families looking for a laid-back, comfortable, and affordable Keys escape. It’s part of a quiet, boutique property with just 7 cottages total, so you get the space and peace of a private place with shared perks like a stunning pool just steps away.

  • Two bedrooms, both with queen beds and clean, simple decor

  • A full kitchen stocked with essentials – fridge, oven, microwave, pots/pans, utensils, coffee maker, and more

  • Comfortable living area to relax after a day on the water

  • Fast, reliable WiFi – whether you’re working remotely or uploading your snorkeling videos

  • Air conditioning throughout the space

  • Fresh linens, bath towels, and starter toiletries provided. 

    • 🌴 Outdoor Living – Florida Keys Style

    You’ll have your own:
    ✔️ Fire pit – light it up for s’mores, a nightcap, or just to unwind under the stars
    ✔️ Grill – perfect for cooking up the day’s catch or some island-style BBQ
    ✔️ Outdoor seating surrounded by tropical greenery

    This is your spot to sip your morning coffee or enjoy a cocktail after a day of exploring.

    🏊‍♂️ Resort-Style Pool (Without the Crowds)

    The pool area is a gem – beautifully maintained and shared with only 6 other cottages, so it’s never crowded. Plenty of space to lounge, float, soak up the sun, or take a dip before heading out to dinner.

    🛶 Free Paddleboards Included

    Want to explore the crystal-clear waters the Keys are famous for? We include paddleboards FREE for guest use! You can easily launch from a nearby ramp and head out to discover mangroves, spot wildlife, or just glide across the turquoise sea. No rentals, no hassle – just grab and go.

    📍 Location, Location, Location

    You’re right in the heart of Islamorada, known as the Sportfishing Capital of the World, but there's so much more here than just fishing.

    ✔️ Robbie’s Marina – just 1 mile away! Feed the tarpon, rent a boat, book a jet ski, or shop the quirky local market
    ✔️ Anne’s Beach – a beautiful, family-friendly stretch of sandy coastline just a 5-minute drive
    ✔️ The Art District – home to local galleries, artisan shops, cafes, and laid-back island vibes
    ✔️ Close to amazing restaurants and tiki bars – fresh seafood, sunset views, tropical cocktails
    ✔️ Easy access to snorkeling, diving, kayaking, and boat tours

    Whether you’re here to explore or just kick back with a drink in your hand, you’re in the perfect spot.

    ☀️ What Guests Love About the Cottage:

    • It’s private, peaceful, and relaxed

    • The pool is beautiful and never crowded

    • You can paddleboard without having to rent anything

    • The outdoor firepit and grill make it feel like your own little backyard in paradise

    • The location makes it easy to get anywhere on the island – beaches, marinas, restaurants, all nearby

    🧳 Other Things to Note:

    • Parking is included and right outside your door

    • Pool towels are provided

    • No smoking inside the cottage

    • We’re happy to give local recommendations – we live here and love it!

What’s included

  • Self check-in

    Self check-in

  • Parking

    Parking

  • Pool

    Pool

  • Washer

    Washer

  • Dryer

    Dryer

  • Air conditioning

    Air conditioning

  • Heating

    Heating

  • Kitchen

    Kitchen

Guest reviews

Star icon 5.0 | 122 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
K

Kari

Star Icon 0 0Star Icon 0 1Star Icon 0 2Star Icon 0 3Star Icon 0 4

March 2026

We really enjoyed our stay at Key Lime Cottage. Jenny was kind, responsive, and easy to communicate with. We loved having the pool to ourselves—it made the stay feel extra relaxing. The location was also perfect, close to everything we wanted to do. Would definitely stay here again!

D

Donna

Star Icon 1 0Star Icon 1 1Star Icon 1 2Star Icon 1 3Star Icon 1 4

February 2026

Jenny was great, place was adorable and lovely and well appointed. Comfortable and outdoor space was really nice too

N

Nicole

Star Icon 2 0Star Icon 2 1Star Icon 2 2Star Icon 2 3Star Icon 2 4

February 2026

Jenny was a fabulous host. She was very responsive and checked in a couple of times to make sure everything was ok and to see if we needed anything. The cottage was comfortable and had everything we needed. I would definitely stay again! Thank you!

P

Penny

Star Icon 3 0Star Icon 3 1Star Icon 3 2Star Icon 3 3Star Icon 3 4

January 2026

We had a fabulous stay at Key Lime Cottage. The cottage is very cozy, well appointed, and impeccably clean. Importantly, it is well located for enjoying this beautiful section of the Keys. We particularly enjoyed the nearby Ann’s Beach. Jenny is a responsive and proactive host. We would recommend the Key Lime Cottage to anyone visiting Islamorada.

Know before you go

Self check-in

House rules

Check-in: 3:00pm

Checkout: 11:00am

No pets allowed

No smoking

No parties

Have a question about this property?

Site Footer

Get deals directly in your inbox:

© 2026 Whimstay, Inc. All Rights Reserved. “SEIZE THE STAY” and “WHIMSTAY” are registered trademarks of Whimstay, Inc. and the W Logo is a trademark of Whimstay, Inc.