1 / 50

Historic Geneva Home: Fireplace & Game Room

House in Geneva, NY

8 guests·4 bedrooms·3 bathrooms
4.9 · 58 reviews

Why you'll love this stay

Outdoor Living

Outdoor Living

Fire pit evenings and spacious outdoor seating for memorable get-togethers.

Entertainment & Amenities

Entertainment & Amenities

Epic game room with pool, darts, karaoke, and discos for all ages.

Value & Savings

Value & Savings

Guests save an average of 20% when booking this stay vs. Airbnb and Vrbo.

Property details

Step back in time without sacrificing comfort at The Historic 98—an 1813 home beautifully restored for modern travelers. With 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, 2 living rooms, and an epic game room, there’s room to relax, play, and reconnect. Located just minutes from downtown Geneva, Seneca Lake, and the Finger Lakes Wine Trail, this home is perfect for couples, families, or friends exploring the region. Quiet hours: 22:00 to 07:00. Pets: Allowed (maximum 1). Smoking: Not allowed. Events: Not allowed. Suitable for: children and infants. Additional rules: Pets are allowed but only if you have prior approval and pet fee is paid. If you do bring your pets, please clean up after them in both the house and the yard. Our pet fee covers additional cleaning required for pet stays, but does not cover any damaged furniture, linens, carpet, etc. This property has a sensitive plumbing system. Please do not flush anything other than toilet paper down the toilets. Please turn off the grill after use. If you moved any outdoor furniture, please put it back where you found it. If you need a pack n play during your stay, please request one through the Get RED-y Concierge App We keep a full inventory of the property and kindly ask that you notify us if anything is broken, damaged, or missing during your stay. Historic charm meets modern fun at this spacious and welcoming retreat. Guests have full access to the entire home and outdoor areas—perfect for gathering, relaxing, and making memories. 🍽️ Main Floor Features 🥘 Eat-In Kitchen – Fully equipped with everything you need for meals at home 🛋️ Two Living Rooms – Cozy seating, smart TVs, books, and a fireplace (decorative) 🎯 Game Room – Play pool or darts, read from the library, or light up the disco balls for karaoke and dancing 🎲 Formal Dining Room – Timeless character and space for a sit-down meal 🚻 Half Bath – Conveniently located off the main living space 🛌 Upstairs Layout 🧭 Front of the House – Two Queen Suites + Hall Workspace Walk up the grand staircase and arrive in the front section of the home, where you'll find: 🛏 Queen Bedroom 1 – A spacious suite featuring a queen bed, a twin bed for additional sleeping space, a cozy seating area, and an electric fireplace insert. The en suite bathroom can also be accessed via a hallway entrance. 🛏 Queen Bedroom 2 – Another elegant queen suite with its own en suite bath, plus a seating area and fireplace insert for added comfort. 💼 Hallway Workspace – A vintage desk area, perfect for remote work or journaling by natural light. 🚪 A charming arched doorway separates the front bedrooms from the rear of the home, offering additional privacy. 🏡 Back of the House – Two Additional Bedrooms + Full Bath Beyond the arch, you’ll find: 🛏 Queen Bedroom 3 – Stylish and comfortable, with a smart TV and additional seating area. 🛏 Single Bedroom – Ideal for a solo guest or child, this room includes a TV and ample closet space. 🛁 Shared Full Bath – Conveniently located just outside both bedrooms, this spacious bathroom also includes a washer and dryer for easy mid-stay laundry. ↩️ Back Staircase – Offers quick access to the lower level of the home. ✨ Property Highlights 🎯 Game Room Fun – Enjoy darts, pool, karaoke, hundreds of books, and not one but two disco balls for an unforgettable night in. 🔥 Fire Pit + Outdoor Living – Roast marshmallows, grill out, or relax under the stars with plenty of outdoor seating. 🎲 Board Games Galore – A wide variety of games for guests of all ages, perfect for cozy evenings. 📻 Vintage Record Player – Spin your favorite tunes and set the mood in this history-rich home. 🛋️ Room to Spread Out – With two living rooms, four bedrooms, and a formal dining room, there's space for everyone to relax and recharge. 🔎 Want a closer look? Take a virtual walk-through of The Historic 98 here: . 📍 Prime Location ☕ Across from Monaco’s Coffee – Start your morning with a local favorite, just steps from your door. 🚶 15-Min Walk to Seneca Lake – Enjoy a scenic stroll to the water’s edge. 🚗 5-Min Drive to Boat Rentals + Lakefront Parks – Quick access to paddle adventures, scenic parks, and lakeside lounging. 🛍️ Close to Downtown Geneva – Discover shops, restaurants, bars, and wine tasting rooms just a few blocks away. 🥾 Explore the Region – Less than an hour to some of the Finger Lakes’ best hiking trails and waterfalls. 🕰️ Fun Facts 🏛️ Built in 1813 – The Historic 98 was constructed by Robert Troup, a Revolutionary War soldier, federal judge, and land agent who helped shape Western New York. 📚 Troup’s Legacy – A lifelong friend and college roommate of both Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr, Troup managed the Pulteney Land Office—located just next door. 📖 History Around Every Corner – From the formal dining room to the ornate archways and curated book collection, this home blends 200+ years of history with thoughtful, modern touches. From its rich history to its cozy comforts and unbeatable location, The Historic 98 is the perfect home base for your Finger Lakes adventure—just show up and settle in. Guests have full private access to the entire home and outdoor spaces. Digital locks are installed on all entry doors for easy self-check-in. We offer 24/7 guest support — we're always just a message or call away if you need anything during your stay. While we’re here to help at any time, we also respect your privacy and won’t interrupt your visit unless absolutely necessary. Set just two blocks from downtown Geneva, The Historic 98 is right in the middle of it all—yet still peaceful and relaxed. Stroll to over 30 restaurants, bars, and tasting rooms, or enjoy the tree-lined charm of Pulteney Park just next door. You're also only a few blocks from the Seneca Lake shoreline, making this the ideal launch point for a wine tour or lakeside adventure. ➡️ Please note: We provide cooking basics, with the exception of oil at this time—it will be included in the future. ➡️ A Pack ’n Play is available BY REQUEST ONLY and provided free of charge. Please let us know in advance if you’d like one so we can have it ready for your arrival. ➡️ Dog Friendly – Well-behaved dogs are welcome with approval and a pet fee. ➡️ Decorative Fireplaces – The fireplaces are for ambiance only and are not functional. ➡️ Seasonal Amenities – Some outdoor features may vary depending on weather and time of year.

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1

1 Queen Bed

Bedroom 2

1 Queen Bed

Bedroom 3

1 Single Bed

Bedroom 4

1 Queen Bed

1 Single Bed

What’s included

  • Parking

    Parking

  • Washer

    Washer

  • Dryer

    Dryer

  • Air conditioning

    Air conditioning

  • Heating

    Heating

  • Fireplace

    Fireplace

  • Kitchen

    Kitchen

  • Wi-Fi

    Wi-Fi

Guest reviews

Star icon 4.9 | 58 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
D

Dee

Star Icon 0 0Star Icon 0 1Star Icon 0 2Star Icon 0 3Star Icon 0 4

October 2026

Great place and location !

M

Michael

Star Icon 1 0Star Icon 1 1Star Icon 1 2Star Icon 1 3Star Icon 1 4

October 2026

My family was there to celebrate a wedding and we had a great time in this historic home. Plenty of space and bathrooms to get ready for the big day. If you are staying in Geneva I would definitely recommend this place.

L

Lisa

Star Icon 2 0Star Icon 2 1Star Icon 2 2Star Icon 2 3Star Icon 2 4

October 2026

Beautiful historic house that’s convenient to shops, restaurants, and other amenities.

B

Borjan

Star Icon 3 0Star Icon 3 1Star Icon 3 2Star Icon 3 3Star Icon 3 4

September 2026

it was great, would stay again

Know before you go

House rules

Check-in: 4:00pm

Checkout: 11:00am

Pets allowed

No smoking

No parties

Have a question about this property?

Site Footer

Get deals directly in your inbox:

© 2026 Whimstay, Inc. All Rights Reserved. “SEIZE THE STAY” and “WHIMSTAY” are registered trademarks of Whimstay, Inc. and the W Logo is a trademark of Whimstay, Inc.