Fishers Retreat
House in Mccordsville, IN
Why you'll love this stay
Outdoor Living
Expansive outdoor setup with lake views ideal for family gatherings.
Location & Accessibility
Easy access to Geist Reservoir and local attractions.
Value & Savings
Guests save an average of 17% when booking this stay vs. Airbnb and Vrbo.
What guests are saying
4.1
Rated 4.1 out of 5 from 40 reviews4.1
Rated 4.1 out of 5 from 40 reviewsGuests consistently praise the spaciousness and beauty of the property, highlighting its suitability for large groups and families. Many appreciate the well-stocked kitchen and the peaceful neighborhood. Communication with the host is often noted as responsive and helpful. However, some guests express concerns about cleanliness and maintenance, with reports of clutter and worn furnishings. Overall, while the property offers a pleasant experience, attention to detail in upkeep could enhance guest satisfaction.
Property details
Sleeping arrangements
Bedroom 1
1 Queen Bed
2 Twin Beds
1 King Bed
Bedroom 2
1 Queen Bed
1 Cribs
Bedroom 3
1 Queen Bed
Bedroom 4
1 King Bed
1 Cribs
Bedroom 5
2 Twin Beds
1 Twin Sofa Bed
Bedroom 6
2 Twin Bunk Beds
1 Queen Bed
1 Queen Sofa Bed
Common space
1 Queen Bed
What’s included
Self check-in
Parking
Washer
Dryer
Air conditioning
Heating
Fireplace
Pets allowed
Guest reviews
Molly
March 2026
This property was not accurately advertised at all. The pictures are not accurate. The living room furniture is completely different and very odd. There were only two older couches placed right next to each other and then some sort of bean bag. The rest of the living room was completely empty. The host was very very quick to respond and my family and I needed a place in a short notice so we didn’t have much choice. We picked this house based on the pictures but were very miss led and surprised when we arrived at the house but again we didn’t have much choice. The house was oddly filled with children’s furniture and toys in every room. As mentioned in the other reviews too, the booking is a minimum of 5 people and $30 per extra person, but the house has 14 beds. There was a many beds as you could possibly fit in a house which was just odd. Even though the seller was responsive and was able to get in at a short notice. This house is not worth the price whatsoever.
Gary
March 2026
As a person who books through AirBnB at least once a month, this was a very difficult host to deal with from the very beginning. Mismatched terms and conditions, excessive fees, and an overall unpleasant stay. their garage door came off track and hit our vehicle and this Host attempted to try and charge us for using the garage door that had broke and has nothing to do with us causing any external damage. As a person who prides themselves in cleaning up and abides by the rules of my host the experience at this home was very unpleasant. Our bedroom linen was not clean upon arrival as well as a few other noticeable items that were left around the house, the house wasn’t totally unclean, but definitely had unacceptable conditions upon our arrival.
Garrett
February 2026
This place filled every need we could have! The neighborhood is beautiful and many of us enjoyed long walks in the morning. Hope was spacious, and had the right amount of beds for our sleeping arrangements!
Tiffany
January 2026
BEWARE. DO NOT STAY HERE! The house is fine, but there are so many potential fines ($500 for this or that). After checking out the hosts decided to pin me with $THOUSANDS in fines. There was some scuffs on the walls and doorframes and a few spots where a previous guest must have poked holes by accident here or there. I've seen plenty of that as normal wear and tear for a rental house and never thought to take photographs to prove that it was there when my family ever checked in. I'm beyond disgusted that they would blame my family for this. I don't know if they decided to pin this on my family due to racist inclinations because they saw that we are of African decent. Regardless, I caution you against staying at this home. Also, all the dishes were dirty, the sink had food in it that I had to scrub out, the kitchen drawers were full of crumbs, so we had to wash everything by hand. And the bed my kids stayed in was very dusty. I could have overlooked that if not for the shameful fines.
Know before you go
House rules
Check-in: 4:00pm
Checkout: 11:00am
Pets allowed
Min. age to rent: 25Minimum age to rent: 25
No smoking
No parties