1 / 44

Catskills Dream Lakehouse - Lake, Pool & Hot Tub

House in Forestburgh, NY

4 guests·2 bedrooms·2 bathrooms
4.9 · 8 reviews

Why you'll love this stay

Outdoor Living

Outdoor Living

Wake to tranquil lake views from a sunlit wraparound deck.

Entertainment & Amenities

Entertainment & Amenities

Soak in a private pool and hot tub with serene lake views.

Location & Accessibility

Location & Accessibility

Secluded 2-hour NYC drive with nearby charming Forestburgh towns.

Property details

Catskills Dream Lakehouse is a 2 bed, 2 bath cottage on 5 private acres with direct access to McAuley's Lake, a stocked lake perfect for fishing, swimming, and paddling. A private beach and dock sit steps from the house, alongside a pool, hot tub, and wraparound deck. A true summer escape, 2+ hrs from NYC. Nearby towns: Forestburgh (10mins), Monticello (20mins), Port Jervis (25mins), Livingston Manor (35mins) Pets: Allowed (maximum 1). Smoking: Not allowed. Events: Not allowed. Suitable for: children and infants. Additional rules: AGE REQUIREMENT Primary guest booking must be 25 years or older. PETS Well-behaved dogs are allowed with prior approval (and $100 fee per pet, per stay). Please clean up after your pet both inside and outside the house. Sorry, cats are not permitted. Failure to disclose any pets in advance may result in additional fees or penalties. If you are traveling with a service animal, we kindly ask that you let us know in advance. SMOKING No smoking is permitted inside the house. If you must smoke, please do so outside and dispose of butts properly.. EXCESSIVE CLEANING FEES We kindly ask that guests treat the home with care and respect. Should the property require cleaning beyond the standard turnover—due to excessive mess or incidents involving bodily fluids such as blood, vomit, or waste—a $500 fee may apply. Any linens or furnishings damaged beyond repair will also be subject to replacement charges. These situations are considered outside the scope of routine housekeeping and require specialized attention to ensure the safety and well-being of our team. MID-STAY CLEANING REQUIREMENT For stays of 28 nights or longer, a guest-paid mid-stay cleaning is required. The cleaning will be scheduled at a mutually convenient time during your stay. The cost varies by property and will be confirmed before scheduling. ACCURATE GUEST COUNT The number of guests must be accurately disclosed at the time of booking. While we don’t charge extra for additional guests up to the home’s maximum occupancy, this information is essential so we can properly prepare and stock the home. Please note that penalties may apply if guest counts are inaccurate or intentionally misrepresented. OUTSIDE SERVICE PROVIDERS Outside staff such as private chefs, massage therapists, or other service providers are welcome, but prior approval is required before they come on-site. SUPPLEMENTAL AGREEMENTS Guests may be required to sign a rental agreement. If applicable, it will be sent after the booking is confirmed. SEPTIC Please be mindful of the septic system and do not flush anything down the toilets or drains other than toilet paper. This includes any and all personal hygiene products, baby wipes, bleaches and strong chemical cleaners. Catskills Dream Lakehouse is a lakeside cottage on a private, forested five-acre lot with its own beach, dock, and direct access to the stocked waters of McAuley's Lake. Cast a line from the dock, launch a kayak, or simply spend the day at the water's edge. The private setting makes it feel like the lake is yours alone. On the main level, an open concept living, dining and kitchen space with spacious high ceilings features cozy seating, a couch with TV, and a gas fireplace, ideal for relaxing after a day outdoors. The kitchen includes a breakfast bar with an adjacent dining nook for four and sliding glass doors open onto the wraparound deck with a screened in area just outside. Upstairs, a loft style primary bedroom features a queen size bed, laptop friendly workspace and an ensuite bathroom with a walk-in shower. The second bedroom, located on the main level, offers a queen size bed plus sliding glass doors that open directly to the outdoors. There is also a full bathroom with a walk-in shower on this level. The wraparound deck holds the grill and extends down to a spacious pool deck where guests can relax by the pool or hot tub and enjoy ample space for dining and entertaining. Lounge in the Adirondack chairs, play games, or enjoy cozy evenings by the fire pit. Whether you’re soaking in the hot tub, swimming in the pool, or just enjoying the view, Catskills Dream Lakehouse offers the ultimate Catskills escape. We love discovering the best of the Catskills, and this area has plenty to offer. Here are some of our favorite things to do nearby: Catch live music, art exhibits, and seasonal festivals at Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, located on the historic site of the 1969 Woodstock festival. Car enthusiasts will enjoy exploring the vintage and classic collection at Churchill Classics. Looking to cool off or keep the kids entertained? Head to The Kartrite Resort, home to New York’s largest indoor waterpark. For a more scenic experience, take a drive along the Upper Delaware Scenic Byway especially beautiful in fall. Feeling lucky? Try your hand at the slots or table games at Resorts World Catskills. For a local brew, don’t miss The Catskill Brewery, known for its sustainable brewing and great beer garden. And for adrenaline seekers, a visit to Monticello Motor Club offers high-speed thrills on a world-class race track. There is no washer/dryer. || Please do not use anti bacterial soap because of the septic. || Please note that the pool closes every year seasonally, just around Labor Day, and reopens typically around Memorial Day. The pool is NOT heated. A/C: There is a window unit located in the living room. The bedrooms have fans.

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1

1 Queen Bed

Bedroom 2

1 Queen Bed

What’s included

  • Parking

    Parking

  • Hot tub

    Hot tub

  • Pool

    Pool

  • Heating

    Heating

  • Fireplace

    Fireplace

  • Kitchen

    Kitchen

  • Wi-Fi

    Wi-Fi

  • Balcony

    Balcony

Guest reviews

Star icon 4.9 | 8 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
M

Marina

Star Icon 0 0Star Icon 0 1Star Icon 0 2Star Icon 0 3Star Icon 0 4

October 2026

We had a wonderful stay! The lake access is absolutely beautiful, the surroundings are incredibly peaceful, and the house is in perfect condition, exactly as shown in the photos. The Red Cottage team was 10/10! We had a few questions during our stay, and they were always quick to respond and very helpful. We would definitely book again!

E

Emily

Star Icon 1 0Star Icon 1 1Star Icon 1 2Star Icon 1 3Star Icon 1 4

August 2026

Beautiful, serene escape with a level of privacy that’s hard to come by in the area. 10/10 would book again!

L

Lucas

Star Icon 2 0Star Icon 2 1Star Icon 2 2Star Icon 2 3Star Icon 2 4

August 2026

We had a great one week stay here. The location is truly magical and the pictures dont fully do it justice - you are surrounded by trees, and have a gorgeous lake view plus pool. The house had a few small details that could use some maintenance but nothing to take away from the overall experience. We could easily drive to hikes, and theres a general store with yummy breakfast food just 5 minutes away.

S

Shulem

Star Icon 3 0Star Icon 3 1Star Icon 3 2Star Icon 3 3Star Icon 3 4

August 2026

We had a very nice experience. The house has everything that's needed. We really enjoyed the pool, the hot tub, and the lake, the beach sand too.

Know before you go

House rules

Check-in: 4:00pm

Checkout: 11:00am

Pets allowed

Min. age to rent: 25

No smoking

No parties

Have a question about this property?

Site Footer

Get deals directly in your inbox:

© 2026 Whimstay, Inc. All Rights Reserved. “SEIZE THE STAY” and “WHIMSTAY” are registered trademarks of Whimstay, Inc. and the W Logo is a trademark of Whimstay, Inc.