1 / 45

Shelter Island Retreat w/ Outdoor Pool!

Entire home in Shelter Island, NY

8 guests·5 bedrooms·6.5 bathrooms
5.0 · 3 reviews

Property details

If you’re looking to escape bustling city life, book this 5-bedroom, 6.5-bath home in the Hamptons area! This Shelter Island vacation rental features an office and free WiFi, as well as amenities like a game room and pool to ensure a productive and restorative stay. With fun activities year-round, you can kayak on the nearby ocean, sip on some wine at the Wölffer Estate Vineyard, witness stunning views from Montauk Point, catch a Polo match, or get your holiday shopping done in the Hamptons!

The space
Seasonal Outdoor Pool | Fully Equipped Home Gym | Free WiFi (High Speed) | 110 Mi to NYC | 5,000 Sq Ft

Bedroom 1: King Bed | Bedroom 2: King Bed | Bedroom 3: 2 Twin Beds | Bedroom 4: 2 Twin Bunk Beds | Bedroom 5: Queen Bed | Bonus Room: King Bed

OUTDOOR LIVING: Private beach w/ wood-burning fire pit & beach chairs, kayaks (available spring/summer months), near ocean, walk to beaches, deck, gas grill + outdoor kitchen area, outdoor fireplace, fire pit, bicycles, boating, beach chairs, beach umbrella, trampoline
INDOOR LIVING: 3 Smart TVs w/ cable, en-suite bathrooms, walk-in closet, laptop-friendly workspace, game room w/ pool table, gas fireplaces, dining areas, jetted bathtub, shower, books
KITCHEN: Refrigerator, stove/oven, blender, toaster, cooking basics
GENERAL: Central A/C + heating, complimentary toiletries, linens/towels, washers/dryers, hair dryer, hangers, beach towels, trash bags/paper towels
FAQ: Steps required for entry, bedroom + bathroom on 1st floor, zero-entrance shower
PARKING: Driveway (7 vehicles)

Guest access
Guests will have access to the entire property via self check-in

Other things to note
- No smoking
- No pets allowed
- No events, parties, or large gatherings
- Additional fees and taxes may apply
- Photo ID may be required upon check-in
- NOTE: There are a few steps required for entry, but there is a bedroom and bathroom with a zero-entrance shower on the main floor
- NOTE: The outdoor pool is open seasonally from May-September and the kayaks are only available in the spring and summer months

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1

1 king Bed

Bedroom 2

1 king Bed

Bedroom 3

2 single Beds

Bedroom 4

1 queen Bed

Bedroom 5

4 single Beds

Common space

1 king Bed

What’s included

  • Private outdoor pool

    Private outdoor pool

  • Washer

    Washer

  • Dryer

    Dryer

  • Central air conditioning

    Central air conditioning

  • Central heating

    Central heating

  • Indoor fireplace

    Indoor fireplace

  • Kitchen

    Kitchen

  • Wifi

    Wifi

Guest reviews

Star icon 5.0 | 3 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
S

Sara

Just Perfect

Star Icon 0 0Star Icon 0 1Star Icon 0 2Star Icon 0 3Star Icon 0 4

September 2024

8 of us old college friends stayed here for 3 nights for our annual reunion. This property on Shelter Island provided everything we might need, and exceeded our expectations. The beds were comfortable. The showers were hot. There were ensuite bathrooms for each bedroom. The kitchen was large and had every utensil needed to cook and serve a group. The dining table accommodated everyone. The living room had a large sectional for relaxing. But the best part was the view, the patio, and the proximity to a gorgeous rocky beach. We sat around and admired the view of the ocean, played bocce (provided with the property), and walked on the beach. It was perfect.

J

Jutta

Highly recommend!

Star Icon 1 0Star Icon 1 1Star Icon 1 2Star Icon 1 3Star Icon 1 4

August 2023

We had a wonderful time at this beautiful house. Our family came together from Germany and NYC to spend two weeks here and we would come back any time. The bedrooms were comfortable and each comes with its own bathroom. The kitchen is perfectly equipped. The terrace made for wonderful BBQs and the pool is a delight. Thanks for a wonderful stay!

K

kerry

The perfect getaway

Star Icon 2 0Star Icon 2 1Star Icon 2 2Star Icon 2 3Star Icon 2 4

June 2023

Though we loved our outings on and around Shelter Island, we would have been just as happy never leaving the property! Our group enjoyed lazy days by the pool and delicious meals cooked at home in the gorgeous kitchen. Ashley was super responsive throughout the weekend, ensuring we had everything we needed. We just checked out last week and are already looking for a week we can come back next year (and hopefully stay even longer).

Know before you go

House rules

Check-in: 3:00pm

Checkout: 10:00am

No pets allowed

Min. age to rent: 18

No smoking

No parties

Have a question about this property?

Site Footer

Get deals directly in your inbox:

© 2026 Whimstay, Inc. All Rights Reserved. “SEIZE THE STAY” and “WHIMSTAY” are registered trademarks of Whimstay, Inc. and the W Logo is a trademark of Whimstay, Inc.